Comparative Critique

Too keep mum to the trick out: The Historical Context for Womens Obsession with Slenderness vs. Rethinking Weight
In the article, Too completion to the Bone: The Historical Context for Womens Obsession with Slenderness, Roberta Seid, the author, tells of the randy and life-changing endeavors women have taken on to try and portray the beau melodic themel bole over time. Going as far indorse as the 115th century, Seid exposes our cultures ideal body image and how it has changed over time. This article unveils the complexity of striving to be the ideal woman with the ideal body. On the contrary, Rethinking Weight, Spake conveys many divergent views of corpulency. Being viewed as prejudice and discrimination, Spake shares the common idea of world overweight, and not losing the weight, is caused by laziness (Spake 284). Too Close to the Bone and Rethinking Weight both discuss weight issues that deal much with the mind than with the body. However, the articles contrast in the ways that Rethinking Weight focuses on the agitation of the medical world. The agitation being if obesity is caused by genetics or if it is a choice, while Too Close to the Bone focuses more solely on women and the complexity of the idea that the ideal body is constantly evolving to our society.



Thus leading to a similarity in that both articles discuss the effects of the mistaken beliefs fueled by our society and misconceptions of historys conceit
of the body.

The article, Too Close to the Bone complicated an idea shown in Rethinking Weight because one believes that a cause of weight problems is gener every(prenominal)y genetics. In Too Close to the Bone by carnal knowledge about the trials and physiological demand that society has on women of all ages, Seid discusses whether or not obesity is just a disease. Seid took low consideration many researchers and doctors opinions of this topic. Considering their opinions helped Seid draw her own conclusions. Thinking of obesity as a disease would simply...If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: Orderessay



If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .